Why the people's Parliament is failing the people

19 September 2017
President Jacob Zuma responding to questions for Oral Reply in the National Assembly in Parliament, Cape Town. Image:&nbsp;GCIS (<a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nd/2.0/" target="_blank" style="font-weight: normal;">CC BY-ND 2.0</a>).
President Jacob Zuma responding to questions for Oral Reply in the National Assembly in Parliament, Cape Town. Image: GCIS (CC BY-ND 2.0).

As long as members of the South African Parliament are selected by – and answerable to – their parties rather than the voters, there will be limited public accountability. So argue two researchers in law in a chapter of a new book on the role of political parties in democratic South Africa. Their insights throw new light on the failure of the recent vote of no confidence in the president and efforts to hold him to account for Nkandla.

South Africa may have gained a ʻpeople’s Parliament’ in 1994, which represented a decisive break from the long years of oppression and illegitimacy, but the legislature often fails to live up to its critical task of holding the executive to account.

This is exacerbated by the dominance of a ruling party for whose members of Parliament (MPs) there is little incentive to adopt independent or critical postures on policy or the conduct of the president or ministers in the Cabinet. The costs of doing so can be high, and without electoral reform that guarantees direct accountability to voters, this is unlikely to change.

This is the key thrust of a collaboration between UCT Professor of Public Law Danwood Chirwa and law lecturer Phindile Ntliziywana in their chapter “Political parties and their capacity to provide parliamentary oversight” in a recent publication, Political Parties in South Africa: do they undermine or underpin democracy?

Chirwa and Ntliziywana acknowledge the development of oversight mechanisms and fundamental shifts in improving accountability since 1994 – from opening parliamentary committee proceedings to the public and the media, to adopting a greater constitutional framework that reinforces public accountability.

“Some good things have happened, especially in the way institutions can be called to account,” says Chirwa. “But it’s when it matters most – in calling the president and cabinet ministers to account – that the system fails.”

Relying on an ethical executive

It only functions, he says, as long as the executive performs well, is ethical and observes the constitutional boundaries that define the separation of powers and the role of other institutions of oversight (such as the public protector).

“But where there’s a failure of accountability and constitutionalism at the top, and if corruption sets in at that level, the system crumbles and fails.”


“Where there’s a failure of accountability and constitutionalism at the top, and if corruption sets in at that level, the system crumbles and fails.”

Toeing the party line

The authors isolate three major impediments. The first is that voters can’t hold individual representatives to account, but can only petition the party to whip them into line.

“If a party does not care about you, that’s the end of it,” says Ntliziywana. “And because the party decides who goes to Parliament, MPs are expected to account to the party. Even if MPs feel strongly about an issue, they are expected to toe the party line, and those who don’t – as we have seen following the most recent vote of no confidence – are singled out for harassment.”

The second deficiency is the dominance of the ANC, he says. “This kills oversight because there is no real threat to the dominant party’s hegemony; it becomes complacent and uses its majority to frustrate oversight. The latest motion of no confidence, for instance, was the eighth, and all of them have failed because the party just throws in the numbers, and that’s it.

“The consequence is that oversight is left to opposition parties.”

Why the EFF’s unorthodox methods may have worked

Ntliziywana observes that the controversy over multimillion-rand state spending on President Jacob Zuma’s Nkandla residence – dealt with in detail in the chapter – is an illustrative case.

“The EFF resorted to unorthodox methods to hold the ruling party to account on this, and – though we may have regretted their rowdy conduct in Parliament – it had the desired effect. If everyone had stuck to parliamentary rules and the conventions of decorum, the ANC would simply have dominated and we would not be where we are today with Nkandla.”


“The EFF resorted to unorthodox methods to hold the ruling party to account on this, and – though we may have regretted their rowdy conduct in Parliament – it had the desired effect.”

The third issue concerns the relationship between the legislature and the executive arising from the “tendency of all parties to take their most senior members to the executive and fill their parliamentary seats with more junior members”.

“MPs are at a political disadvantage in holding to account members of the executive who also occupy senior posts in the party,” he says. “This further hampers oversight.”

Accountability is a critical condition

Chirwa and Ntliziywana argue that accountability is the “critical” condition of “establishing a functional democracy that fulfils its promises to its people”.

Yet, they write, as long as parties, and not voters, call the shots, there are “no incentives for MPs to exercise independent judgment” and – particularly where members of the executive have been accused of wrongdoing – they have tended to recoil into their party shells, thereby failing to act collectively to hold the executive to account.

Creative Commons License This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Please view the republishing articles page for more information.

New Generation of Academics Programme (nGAP)


UCT has responded energetically to the New Generation of Academics Programme (nGAP), an opportunity provided by the Department of Higher Education (DHET) to build a new generation of black South African academics. The DHET’s 2015 vision document, “Staffing South Africa’s Universities Framework: A comprehensive, transformative approach to developing future generations of academics and building staff capacity”, proposes a suite of initiatives to address the challenge, with nGAP being the major instrument to increase the numbers of black South African academics.

The programme “involves the recruitment of highly capable scholars as new academics, against carefully designed and balanced equity considerations and in light of the disciplinary areas of greatest need”. The nGAP scholars are appointed into permanent positions where from the outset their conditions are customised to ensure their successful induction into the ranks of established academics.

The DHET provides funding over a six-year period to support the appointment of an nGAP lecturer, and their time is protected to provide the best possible opportunity for the completion of a doctorate degree in the shortest possible time. Once the degree is completed, the nGAP lecturer’s teaching commitments are steadily increased until they shoulder a full teaching load.

Since the first advertisement for nGAP posts in 2015, UCT has been awarded 17 nGAP positions: 5 (Phase 1), 4 (Phase 2), 3 (Phase 3) and 5 (Phase 4). These are distributed across all faculties.

UCT’s nGAP scholars operate as a single cohort, managed and coordinated by Dr Robert Morrell. Lecturers meet for quarterly meetings, writing retreats and various capacity-building activities all designed to support the completion of postgraduate qualifications (particularly doctorates) and to develop records of achievement that will testify to their emergence as self-standing, excellent academics. Each lecturer is mentored by a senior scholar, who provides support and guidance on the challenges that routinely face academics.

The nGAP manager sets great store in building the cohesion of the cohort and encouraging the establishment of new UCT networks while producing a collaborative, mutually supportive and embracing work culture.

According to Dr Morrell, “This group of academics will lead UCT in 15 to 20 years’ time ... Their vision of excellence, of being African and South African, of serving a wider community and producing knowledge for the planet, the continent and the country, will power UCT in years to come.”



May 2021 10:00, 3 May 2021
April 2020 09:00, 29 April 2020
October 2019 12:50, 25 October 2019
March 2019 14:50, 22 March 2019
November 2018 20:30, 5 November 2018
July 2018 10:30, 15 July 2018
February 2018 08:30, 21 February 2018
October 2017 10:30, 15 October 2017


In the news

Bianca Arendse: New nGAP lecturer Bianca Arendse joined Organisational Psychology in the School of Management Studies in the commerce faculty at UCT as a Phase 5 nGAP lecturer at the beginning of 2020. 29 Apr 2020
Maxwell Tawanda Chirehwa: New nGAP associate Maxwell Chirehwa is a research officer in the Division of Clinical Pharmacology in the Department of Medicine at UCT and has recently been appointed as an nGAP associate. 29 Apr 2020
Melissa-Rose Abrahams published in Science Translational Medicine Melissa-Rose Abrahams was the first author on a paper published in October 2019 in the Science Translational Medicine journal. 29 Apr 2020
Musa Nxele: Paris, Parish and a PhD Musa Nxele has recently returned from Paris, France, after spending months studying towards his PhD. 29 Apr 2020
Anatomy of a transformation Transforming an entire academic section – staff, curriculum, texts and culture – takes an exceptional team with big vision. Meet the winners of the 2019 Vice-Chancellor’s Transformation Award. 02 Dec 2019
nGAP: Growth, profile and consolidation Writing retreats provide a chance for sustained writing, and many take advantage of this, waking up early and burning the midnight oil. 22 Oct 2019
Department of Higher Education creates a task team on gender-based violence In May Naledi Pandor, then Minister of Higher Education and Training (DHET), appointed a Task Team to advise her on how to help to prevent sexual harassment and sexual violence at universities. 22 Oct 2019
Award, public profile and international conferences – nGAP makes its mark Philile Mbatha, Amanda Mtya, Kentse Mpolokeng and Taahira Goolam Hoosen have been busy. 22 Oct 2019
Zevenwacht writing retreat Writing retreats are a staple of nGAP life. These quarterly events are held at local conference venues and provide ideal conditions for writing, reflection and connection. 22 Oct 2019
Andiswa Mfengu: New nGAP associate Andiswa Mfengu is a lecturer in the Department of Knowledge and Information Stewardship. 22 Oct 2019
Muzi Sikhonde: New nGAP member Muzi Sikhonde has just joined the Numeracy Centre in the Centre for Higher Education and Development (CHED). 22 Oct 2019
Nastassja Koen: New nGAP member Nastassja joined nGAP in August 2019 having successfully applied for a Phase 5 position. She is a senior lecturer in the Department of Psychiatry and Mental Health. 22 Oct 2019
Envisioning a bright future Rising UCT academic Mochelo Lefoka says he has his grandparents to thank for instilling in him an understanding of the value of a quality education. 10 Dec 2018
Book launch inspires budding scientists The interactive launch of UCT academic Xolisa Guzula’s isiXhosa translation of the children’s book by Lucy and Stephen Hawking took place last week. 19 Jun 2018
Why the people's Parliament is failing the people Two researchers in law offer new insights into the failure of the recent no-confidence vote and efforts to hold the president to account for Nkandla. 19 Sep 2017
How do youth find their place in the world? A UCT contingent’s July 2017 trip to Japan kick-started a research project that interrogates how citizenship is experienced and claimed by young South Africans and Japanese. 07 Sep 2017
UCT in M&G’s top 200 UCT students, alumni and staff have put in a strong showing on the 2017 Mail & Guardian 200 Young South Africans list. 14 Jul 2017
Translating a path to success Xolisa Guzula is working hard to ensure that isiXhosa-speaking children are able to learn and read in their own language. 11 Jul 2017
Decolonial Alternatives Project Space A former burial ground for black men, women and children who were taken into slavery on the Rustenburg slave plantation during the early colonial period will be developed into a unique heritage site at UCT. 14 Sep 2016
Meet a new generation of UCT academics Five new members of staff – all part of the New Generation of Academics Programme (nGAP) – speak about what brought them to UCT, and what they're doing to advance the fields of public law, anatomy, African studies, architecture and human geography. 26 May 2016
PhD examines complex governance systems in Kosi Bay It was the timely intervention of a far-sighted early mentor, Professor Dianne Scott, in Philile Mbatha's honours year at the University of KwaZulu-Natal that changed the course of her life. 26 May 2016
Professionalisation the tonic for municipalities' dysfunction Violent service protests across the country reflect the disjuncture between the needs of civil society's poorest and local government's roll-out of resources and services. It's a topic close to Phindile Ntliziywana's heart. One of UCT's five New Generation of Academics Programme (nGAP) participants, Ntliziywana's PhD examines how the public service, specifically local government, can be improved. 17 May 2016
'Why do we still aspire to whiteness?' Zuziwe Msomi, an nGAP* lecturer in the Centre for African Studies, is interrogating racial identity in post-apartheid South Africa. 16 May 2016
Sadiq Toffa, the nGAP scholar with a commitment to transformative knowledge The New Generation of Academics Programme (nGAP) is an initiative funded by the Department of Higher Education and Training (DHET) in partnership with individual universities that recruits young scholars into permanent academic positions at South African universities. 03 May 2016
"Bold" Mpolokeng believes in the beauty of her dreams When Kentse Mpolokeng took up an nGAP* lectureship in anatomy at UCT at the beginning of this year, she was fulfilling a career ambition that she had spelled out to an interview panel years ago. But it almost didn't happen. 15 Apr 2016