The fight against TB shifts to fixing the immune system, not only bacteria

05 April 2016 | Story Newsroom. Photo Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's Public Health Image Library.)
An anteroposterior X-ray of a patient diagnosed with advanced bilateral pulmonary tuberculosis. This AP X-ray of the chest reveals the presence of bilateral pulmonary infiltrate (white triangles), and "caving formation" (black arrows) present in the right apical region.The diagnosis is far-advanced tuberculosis.
An anteroposterior X-ray of a patient diagnosed with advanced bilateral pulmonary tuberculosis. This AP X-ray of the chest reveals the presence of bilateral pulmonary infiltrate (white triangles), and "caving formation" (black arrows) present in the right apical region.The diagnosis is far-advanced tuberculosis.

Tuberculosis (TB) has managed to remain a major global health problem, despite 100 years of research and more than 50 years of treatment being available. It still claims up to 1.5 million lives each year.

Although there have been ongoing efforts that provide some hope in the fight against the disease, the TB drug pipeline remains thin and vaccine development slow as resistance grows.

More than 9.6 million new TB cases were recorded in 2014. This prompted the Stop TB Partnership and the World Health Assembly to set a target of reducing TB-related deaths by 95% and cases by 90% by 2035. But new therapeutic and diagnostic interventions – including an effective vaccine – are urgently needed if these goals are to be achieved.

Recently there has been an increasing focus on alternative treatment strategies known as host-directed therapies. These are mostly drugs and therapies that have been developed to treat other diseases and conditions such as diabetes or inflammation and then re-purposed to tackle TB.

What makes these therapies unique and important is that after 60 years of targeting the bacteria that kills TB, these treatments open a new door in the fight against infection. They focus on fixing the body rather than the bacteria.

If successful, these alternative treatments will add huge value by addressing the clinical demands around treating TB.

Alternative approaches

Host-directed therapies work differently from TB drug treatments. TB treatment drugs target the bacteria that causes TB. Host-directed therapies focus on areas in the lung that encourage the TB infection. They have two major goals:

  • to improve the state of the immune system, which must be intact to fight off TB; and

  • to limit lung tissue destruction.

Limiting tissue destruction is important because it prevents the disease from progressing. Tissue destruction can be the result of an overwhelming inflammation that destroys important cells in the immune system where the infection occurs. This may lead to cavities forming in the lung. The bacteria that causes TB is then able to disseminate throughout the lung and is coughed out through the airway.

A number of host-directed therapies currently being investigated could potentially be used for adjunctive TB therapy. These include:

  • vitamin D, which induces specific immune molecules that have protective effects against the TB bacteria;

  • the diabetes drug, metformin, which has been shown to enhance the body's immune responses and decrease the TB bacterial loads in the lung;

  • non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs that limit inflammation and tissue pathology. Inflammation leads to lung damage and progression of the disease; and

  • statins that reduce cholesterol levels and limit bacterial growth in the body's immune cells. Cholesterol is known to encourage the growth of bacteria.

When these therapies are used in combination with standard treatment regimens that target the bacteria, they are likely to shorten the current course of treatment.


Mohlopheni Marakalala speaks about host directed therapies at the Next Einstein Forum.


Why we need alternatives

There are several challenges that affect TB eradication.

First, the TB burden has been aggravated by HIV co-infection. HIV compromises the immune response required to protect a person against TB. This increases vulnerability to the disease. The World Health Organisation's most recent global TB report shows that of the TB-related deaths in 2014, just under 27% of patients were HIV-positive. This is a slight increase from 2012.

A second challenge is drug resistance.

First-line drug regimens have saved millions of lives but have been marred by non compliance and inconsistent use. TB patients who fail to adhere to their drug regimens often develop drug resistant TB. This means they have to go onto second-line drugs which are more expensive and may take even longer to complete.

Further resistance to second-line drugs leads to extensively drug-resistant TB (XDR-TB). This is more difficult to treat.

Drug resistance has led to a number of patients not responding to current treatment protocols, which is why there is a dire need for more treatment options.

The third challenge is that there is no adequate vaccine for adults.

The only approved TB vaccine, Bacille Calmette-Guérin, introduced 95 years ago, reduces the risk of TB in children. But it does not help adults with lung TB. An efficacious vaccine that provides a reliable protection against pulmonary TB is essential to eradicate TB.

In the past ten years, there has been some progress in developing a vaccine. A new candidate, MVA85A, reached a phase 2b clinical trial.

Although MVA85A failed the clinical end point trial due to limited efficacy, several lessons were gained from the study. These will be highly beneficial in guiding future vaccine development efforts.

Currently over a dozen preventive vaccine candidates are progressing through the development pipeline, providing some hope in achieving the 2035 targets.

Other interventions that could help

There are several other areas that need to be looked at to help eradicate TB.

First, the rapid diagnostic tools that can detect latent TB, drug-susceptible TB and drug-resistant TB need to be improved to detect the disease earlier.

Second, patients that do not respond to current treatments due to drug resistance do not have any other alternatives. A new strategy is needed here.

Finally, combination therapy hasn't been cracked. This would shorten treatment protocols, thus improving adherence.

By Mohlopheni Marakalala, Senior Lecturer and Group Leader in the Division of Immunology, University of Cape Town. Main image public domain at Pixabay.


This article first appeared in The Conversation, a collaboration between editors and academics to provide informed news analysis and commentary. Its content is free to read and republish under Creative Commons; media who would like to republish this article should do so directly from its appearance on The Conversation, using the button in the right-hand column of the webpage. UCT academics who would like to write for The Conversation should register with them; you are also welcome to find out more from

The Conversation


This article is featured in the latest Research at UCT newsletter. Be the first to get the latest research news by subscribing.

Creative Commons License This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Please view the republishing articles page for more information.